Our Story
Bethel African Methodist Episcopal Church, incorporated in 1843, is the oldest African American church in Huntington. Located at 291 Park Avenue, it has served the community for more than 175 years. The original incorporators were brickyard workers from West Neck (now Lloyd Harbor), and many of the founders and their families are buried in the cemetery behind the church. Early records were lost to fire, but history tells us that prayer meetings and services first took place in the homes of members near Wall Street in Huntington.
On June 5, 1843, the church was formally incorporated with the election of five trustees, and in 1844 the congregation purchased a building known as “The Seminary.” By the mid-1800s, the church became known as Bethel AME of Huntington, a name that continues today. From its earliest days, Bethel has stood as a beacon of faith and unity, and it remains a spiritual home that honors its legacy while welcoming all who seek community and worship.
Our Doors Are Open!
Find encouragement, hope, and community this Sunday — you belong here.
Our Pastor, Rev. Anthony Mitchell
Rev. Anthony Mitchell is a devoted servant-leader who has dedicated his life to ministry, education, and community uplift. Born and raised in East Harlem, he combined his academic pursuits with a deep spiritual calling, earning advanced theological degrees while serving faithfully in the AME Church. Over more than three decades, he has nurtured youth programs, launched afterschool and summer initiatives, advocated for vulnerable communities, and strengthened congregations through both pastoral care and practical leadership. Known for his compassion, integrity, and vision, Rev. Mitchell continues to inspire hope and healing, leaving a lasting impact on every community he serves.
Pastoral Team
Rev. William Spencer, Associate Minister
Bro. Paul Follo, Licentiate
Musicians
Bro. Joseph Waring, Organist
Hugo Lopez, Percussionist
Stewards & Trustees
| Officer Name | Title | Officer Name | Title |
| Rodney Marve | Pastor’s Steward | Ulysses Spicer | Vice-Chair, Steward |
| Geneva Addison | Steward | Nora Conner | Steward |
| Ruthanne Cooley | Vice-Chair, Trustee | Leona Brown | Trustee |
| Sandy Byars-Howard | Trustee | Paul Follo | Trustee |
| Robert Vaughn | Trustee | Richard Robertson, Jr. | Steward |
Photo Gallery
NAACP Martin Luther King Celebration
2026 NAACP Martin Luther King Celebration
